September 27, 2024
|
Research paper

Existential Hunger | L4 Counselling Research Assignment

SHARE

Assignment 4 – Research Project

‘Existential Hunger – An exploration of existential therapy to aid eating disorder recovery.’

By John Liot

“I, A Stranger and Afraid in a World I Never Made” – Alfred Edward Housman

Overview:

The NHS website defines an eating disorder (ED) as “a mental health condition where you use the control of food to cope with feelings and other situations” (NHS, 2021). It is, essentially, where an individual experiences a non-harmonious relationship with food – a relationship that causes strife for the person on a biological, social, or existential level. There are, currently, eight defined types of eating disorder (Kelvas, 2023). These conditions range from the broadly (yet often superficially) understood like Bulima (binge eating) and Anorexia Nervosa (severely restricted eating), to less popularised conditions like Rumination Disorder; a condition where an individual eats food, regurgitates and then consumes the food again, possibly repeating this process several times. Given how far humans have navigated away from our hunter-gatherer days, what a harmonious relationship with food would’ve looked like then, and into our modern-day realities where food can be disconcertingly man-made, is it a surprise that, for many of us, our fundamental relationship with food is just as distorted? Food would’ve, at one point, been a matter of scarcity and ‘eat what’s available’ (Pobiner, 2017). Indeed, it’s hard to imagine that early humans ever ate to quell boredom, yet it is a somewhat textbook example of contemporary human existence to recline and eat snacks until we feel sick (Moynihan et al., 2015). We have moved from food representing survival, to food representing something else: social acceptance (eating ‘the right’ food), self-esteem (treats, indulgence), punishment (restricting food), status (eating foods of perceived worth and standing), mood (eating foods to influence mood – aphrodisiacs, superfoods) and more.

This paper focuses on eating disorders from a western perspective – citing research from UK and North American sources. Even within poverty-stricken parts of these locations, the proximity and abundance of food still separates us from early humans that needed to forage or hunt for food. Such a distinction is important to recognise, as societally, food has changed. The concept of a supermarket or an all-you-can-eat buffet really flies in the face of our ancestors who clung to life with each meal. Along the way, the relationship between humans and food evolved. Many of us remain with a harmonious connection to food, though others haven’t. In such cases, the relationship to the only thing more fundamental to human existence than water and air can become toxic. The human brain is able to distort the relationship of food to make it an enemy. Despite being a necessity for life, a brain under the control of an eating disorder, like Anorexia Nervosa, can restrict food to the point of death (National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), 2021). The cruellest aspect of an eating disorder being that the solution seems so easy: eat. Ultimately, this is what will bring someone away from the perils of an eating disorder too, so it’s hard for those working with the individual with anorexia to not shout this aid at ever increasing volumes. Yet, for everything written above that relates a person’s relationship with food being the problem, it is, in fact, not food that is the problem to solve. It is the person’s relationship to themselves, their environment, their mortality, that informs these maladaptive relationships with food.

In her biography, ‘The Opposite of Butterfly Hunting’, Evanna Lynch comments that her fall into restricted eating came, at least partially, from a belief she wasn’t deserving of occupying any more space than she could fit in, so the solution became to eat less, become smaller, occupy less space, feel more validated compared to those who confidently inhabited their own space (Lynch, 2021). Lynch’s writing exposes how a once harmonious relationship with food upended itself somewhere around the time of experiencing her older sisters going through puberty and how, for her, a woman’s worth became tied in the idea of sexual development, career goals, and other societal expectations. What predisposed Lynch to restricted eating, where so many other girls of a similar standing were not, remains a mystery – some research is pointing to genetic predispositions that we inherit from our parents and grandparents that may make us susceptible in the right conditions (Berrettini, 2004). Throughout her writing, Lynch details time spent in various medical environments, but also time with a therapist. These sessions represent the clearest path away from disordered eating early on, although they alone were not enough for the eating disorder to dissolve away. However, Lynch touches on a profound success of talking therapy compared to other medical interventions she’d experienced, when, in her first session with her therapist, she reveals she is simply asked how she is doing. For the first time, instead of being told what to do or simply speaking about herself as a personified eating disorder and problem to be solved, Lynch is asked how she, as an individual entity, is coping within her experience of reality. It brings her to tears, though at the time she isn’t sure why. Sadly, due to her age (Lynch not yet a teenager at this point), such explorations are scary, and the ironic security of the eating disorder is threatened enough to keep her from further exploration.

Lynch’s account of life with an eating disorder is by no means prescriptive or to be over-generalised to understand anyone else’s experience. However, her candid and reflective writing does a lot to educate people of all connectivity to eating disorders (even those without such) on what the internal struggle really feels like. Lynch’s revelations about exploring what purpose of life means to her is a signifier that perhaps diets and controlled intake of food are not the path out of eating disorders, but instead, self-reflection, self-assessment, and self-fulfilment. This paper will explore contemporary research to explore whether this casual thesis holds merit.

Current Research

Fortunately, when looking for research into whether there is a positive connection between existential therapy and eating disorders, plenty of work has been done. Not unsurprisingly, key figures within existential philosophy and psychotherapy are not far from sight in these research journals. Irvin Yalom, often regarded as the world’s current leader in existential psychotherapy, as well as Martin Heidekker, who give us foundational principles for modern existentialism, are oft quoted or used as linchpins of literature.

In an illuminating study done in 2001, Michael Thomas discovered a positive link between clients presenting with various eating disorders (anorexia nervosa, bulimia, and morbid obesity), and success in therapy when an existential modality was used.

“…the data indicates that individuals with disordered eating gain more benefit when the therapeutic focus is less on restoring appropriate eating habits and more on the individuals sense of Self;” (Thomas, 2001)

What Thomas was able to gleam from his data was an understanding of why certain types of therapy are unsuccessful for those with EDs. Namely, when the person with the ED views an outside source (the therapist, or other mental health provision) of coming into their life and forcibly removing the ED, they put up resistance (Thomas, 2001, pp160-161). Thomas’ data showed that EDs become a means of the person escaping their reality through numbness, a numbness attained through the substantial lack, or over-indulgence of glucose (Thomas, 2001, p160). In essence, intervention to halt this behaviour didn’t work because it went against the client’s internal logic – namely, they wanted to feel numb, so positions that would attempt to remove this sensation were view as the antagonist. Instead, the most successful therapeutic interventions were found when the ED was acknowledged but left unopposed (and even left as a consistent behaviour during therapy – as contrasting to many addiction-based therapies that require the user to be sober in order to access therapy). In this space, the focus of the therapy became directed away from negative habits and moved into self-awareness and self-actualising topics. Focusing on the person, not the behaviour. From there, the patients in the study reported much stronger desires to change their habits, recognising the damage of the ED and how that interfered with their desires for self-actualisation. 

Existential interventions are anchored in the self-awareness of mortality, that is, in acknowledging a human-being as a creature uniquely aware of their impending death, we have constructed such modalities to alleviate the anxieties brought on by this profoundly human experience (Masterson, 2023).

In a scientific survey, Madison Weinstock of Texas Christian University, collated data of 235 people, 49 with eating disorders, in which their fear of death was explored. The results of her study found that, conclusively, people with eating disorders reported higher sensitivity to their mortality and suggested that such existential dread was characteristic of eating disorders. This data, Weinstock posits, potentially points towards evidential reasoning that the presence of EDs in a person’s life is caused, in some part, by unresolved anxiety relating to mortality.

“…a therapist working with a patient would be able to address anxiety-buffers (e.g. close personal relationships, self-esteem, and worldview beliefs) as a method of reducing disordered eating patterns. In addition, future research could aim to understand whether bolstering the damaged anxiety buffers (i.e., improving self-esteem) could decrease the use of maladaptive eating patterns.” (Weinstock, 2019, p15)

Both sets of research, from Thomas and Weinstock, respectively, suggest that a fundamental source of aid for individuals with eating disorders comes from focusing on their world view, sense of self-esteem and self-fulfilment, and their reaction to mortality. It becomes clear that present research points towards a type of logical justification for eating disorders to arise – not that they are themselves beneficial but much like how anxiety is a means of a warning (that unfortunately can be misunderstood, abstract, and extremely uncomfortable in certain situations) so too could eating disorders be a manifest of incongruence with one’s path to self-actualisation. It makes me a consider a friend, who, upon breaking up with a boyfriend of several years with hopes to one day have children, instead found herself single and suddenly decidedly anti-child. Within days a previously conquered eating disorder returned and latched onto her with vicious intent. Could it be suggested that such a profound detachment to two things that stave off death-anxiety (close personal relationships, child-rearing) brought about the onset of the eating disorder?

What this research alludes to is how the existential modality allows for the therapy to focus truly on the client’s agenda. In many ways, it highlights how a course of aid within a therapeutic space is not so straightforward as to point to the problem and say, ‘there, that, that’s what we need to focus on’. Instead, when understanding that an ED is not a habit out of choice, but a coping mechanism in response to a multitude of life variables (Sigg and Armstrong, 2017), it becomes more pertinent to focus on that lived experience of the client and not the habit causing distress. In simplistic terms, they know that it is causing distress, but it is nonetheless serving a purpose. It matters to their survival, to simply attempt to remove it without bolstering the foundations of the life it exists within is to ask a person adrift to throw away their damaged lifejacket and commit to swimming to a boat they themselves cannot see or trust to be as stable.

Adding to these findings, though presenting a less clear narrative, in a study conducted by Fox and Leung (2008) where two groups of women with anorexia nervosa were surveyed against various control groups to see if they reported as having lower existential well-being scores, as well as other mental health ailments, such as depression, the following was discovered. Interestingly, the results of the study showed a correlation of low existential well-being in the anorexic group that represented women over 30 years old. This lends itself to the emerging concept that with more ‘miles on the clock’, so to speak, the over-30s were more mindful of existential concerns which could impact on the development and appearance of their disordered eating. To contrast this, however, and throw the theory in flux, the younger group (18 – 30 year olds) did not show a difference regarding existential well-being compared to the control group. A possible interpretation of this data is to consider that for women, specifically, the decade of 30 is one that comes with a large degree of existential and social worry. 35 is often regarded as a benchmark for women wanting to have children, the awareness being that after 35 the mother would be at a much higher risk of complications during pregnancy, and a lower chance of getting pregnant as is (Mayo Clinic, 2015). Considering that eating disorders can have numerous and life-long side-effects for a woman’s physiology, especially related to fertility, is it surprising that the over-30 group had higher existential concerns compared to younger women? This is evidenced by the frightening statistic that potentially as many as 89% of women with anorexia nervosa will experience amenorrhea (absence of menstruation) during their illness (Hoffman, et al, 2014). Of course, that is just an interpretation of the data, one that I believe holds water to be considered when we look at these individuals from a journey of life perspective. Conversely, the younger test group not showing lower levels of existential well-being compared to their control could present that this theory is lacking more substance, though could also add to the theory by suggesting that before 30 the anorexic group are more likely to put off such big existential dilemmas as, ‘do I want to have children?’, ‘can I have children?’

In his book, Staring at the Sun (2008), eminent psychotherapist, Irvin D. Yalom, conveys within a title how intense existential concerns are. The phrase, ‘Staring at the Sun’, suggests that acknowledging mortality (which is to say that existential anxiety and death anxiety are two sides of the same coin) is akin to looking directly at something that is ever-present, but to do so causes immediate distress. In this sense, it is reasonable to present that though someone struggles with their existential well-being, their awareness of it may not always be as clear. It could be argued that every child is burdened by the existential awareness of death, though that doesn’t mean they are truly aware of it for many years, if not decades. Yalom, himself, presents a philosophical working theory for the prevalence of death anxiety in a person’s life:

“…the more unlived your life, the greater your death anxiety. The more you fail to experience your life fully, the more you will fear death.”

Irvin Yalom, Staring at the Sun, pp49-50

This presents the consideration to underpin the previous data, at what age do we become aware of our lives having been ‘lived fully’? On an existential timeline, when do we become aware of time being a fleeting commodity, and at the onset of such knowledge, what does this do to our existential wellbeing? EDs often, though not exclusively, begin in adolescence and can persist for years. Statistics suggest that the average age for the onset of anorexia nervosa and bulimia in the UK are 16-17 years old and 18-19 years old, respectively (Priory Group, 2019). The maladaptive coping mechanism of an eating disorder is antithetical to a life lived fully, so it suggests that the prevalence and awareness of low existential wellbeing is as muted as the individual with an eating disorder is to how damaging the eating disorder is to their social connections and physical capacities.

Conclusion

The above research points to existential well-being being a potential driving factor in the appearance and strength of an eating disorder like anorexia nervosa and bulimia. But why is an existential modality effective, specifically, when therapies like CBT also focus on quality of life yet can often fail against the trappings of an eating disorder? (Troscianko, 2018)

Much is made of an eating disorder as an almost malevolent being, distinct from the body it terrorises, however it appears important within the therapeutic space to not dehumanize the individuals experience by creating a disconnect between mind and body. Instead, seeing the individual with an ED as a whole making choices based on logic and reason (regardless of the maladaptive nature and outcomes) and treating them nonjudgmentally is what creates the connection, the ‘in’, for the ED to be approached and challenged.

“Personally, when it comes to anorexia recovery, I don’t approve of solely treating the body and turning a deaf ear to the soul crying out for help. A soul can still drown in a healthy body.”
Evanna Lynch, The Opposite of Butterfly Hunting: The Tragedy and The Glory of Growing Up; A Memoir, 2021

In her memoir, Lynch speaks with gravitas on her experience of working with a therapist who, despite never being cited as such, appears to work within an existential framework. ‘Natasha’, the pseudonym given to this mental health professional, spends significant time creating a nonjudgemental and relationship-driven space for her client, Lynch. Lynch speaks of how disarming this was for her, compared to the cold and meticulous medical practice applied to her by doctors within hospitals previously. Moving from a focus on numbers on a scale, the ingestion of calories, the negative connotations of the eating disorder, and reframing treatment as Lynch learning about who she is, and why she would even have an eating disorder, is ultimately where she points to this type of therapy being successful. It can be interpreted that what Natasha accomplishes through existential therapy with Lynch is not seeing her as a problem to be solved, but a story to hear, a tale to reflect on, allowing Lynch to do the same herself and bring to the forefront, the maladaptive perspectives on life that created the environment for her eating disorder to grow.

“It was just the only way I knew to get by in life by now, the tools I’d picked up to arm myself against the inevitable pain of existing, because nobody had managed to teach me an alternative.”
Evanna Lynch, The Opposite of Butterfly Hunting: The Tragedy and The Glory of Growing Up; A Memoir, 2021

The reflective testimony of Lynch, coupled with numerous scientific studies points to a positive emergence of eating disorder treatment within existential therapy due to it, as a modality, focusing on the person as a whole; their unique perspective of life, their unique sense of the meaning of life, their unique interpretation of meaning and fulfilment, and using this to challenge behaviours that sit oppositional to the life the individual wants for themselves.

‌

Reference list

Evanna Lynch (2021). OPPOSITE OF BUTTERFLY HUNTING : the Tragedy and the Glory of Growing up. 1st ed. S.L.: Headline Book Publishing.

Fox, A. and Leung, N. (2008). Existential well-being in Younger and Older People with Anorexia Nervosa—a Preliminary Investigation. European Eating Disorders Review, [online] 17(1). Available at: https://doi.org/10.1002/erv.895 [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Franko, D.L. and Rolfe, S. (1996). Countertransference in the Treatment of Patients with Eating Disorders. Psychiatry, 59(1), pp.108–116. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/00332747.1996.11024753.

Hoffman, E.R., Zerwas, S.C. and Bulik, C.M. (2014). Reproductive Issues in Anorexia Nervosa. Expert Review of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, [online] 6(4). Available at: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1586/eog.11.31 [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Kelvas, D. (n.d.). 12 Different Types of Eating Disorders | DSM-5 & Related. [online] withinhealth.com. Available at: https://withinhealth.com/learn/articles/types-of-eating-disorders [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Masterson, S. (2023). What Is Existential therapy? | Types of Therapy. [online] www.bacp.co.uk. Available at: https://www.bacp.co.uk/about-therapy/types-of-therapy/existential-therapy/ [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Mayo Clinic. (2015). Pregnancy after 35: What You Need to Know. [online] Available at: https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/getting-pregnant/in-depth/pregnancy/art-20045756#:~:text=After%20age%2035%2C%20there%27s%20a [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Moynihan, A.B., Tilburg, W.A.P. van, Igou, E.R., Wisman, A., Donnelly, A.E. and Mulcaire, J.B. (2015). Eaten up by boredom: Consuming Food to Escape Awareness of the Bored Self. Frontiers in Psychology, [online] 6. doi:https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00369.

National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH). (2021). Eating Disorders: About More Than Food. [online] Available at: https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/eating-disorders#:~:text=Over%20time%2C%20anorexia%20nervosa%20can.

NHS (2021). Overview – Eating Disorders. [online] NHS. Available at: https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/feelings-symptoms-behaviours/behaviours/eating-disorders/overview/ [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Pobiner, B. (2017). Meat-Eating among the Earliest Humans. [online] American Scientist. Available at: https://www.americanscientist.org/article/meat-eating-among-the-earliest-humans [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Priory Group (2019). Eating Disorder Statistics. [online] Priorygroup.com. Available at: https://www.priorygroup.com/eating-disorders/eating-disorder-statistics [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Sigg, C. and Armstrong, L.L. (2017). Swallowing the ‘Givens’ of Existence. Counselling and Spirituality, [online] 36(1-2). Available at: https://poj.peeters-leuven.be/content.php?id=3285230&url=article [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Thomas, M. (2001). EXISTENTIAL INTERVENTIONS IN EATING DISORDERSEXISTENTIAL INTERVENTIONS IN EATING DISORDERS. [online] Available at: https://eprints.nottingham.ac.uk/11482/1/364403.pdf [Accessed 1 Jul. 2024].

Troscianko, E.T. (2018). CBT for Eating Disorders: a Not-Yet-Success Story. [online] Psychology Today. Available at: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/hunger-artist/201805/cbt-eating-disorders-not-yet-success-story [Accessed 2 Jul. 2024].

Weinstock, M. (2019). Understanding the Need for Existential Meaning Amongst Those with Disordered Eating. [online] Available at: https://repository.tcu.edu/bitstream/handle/116099117/27078/Honors_Thesis_2_.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y [Accessed 1 Jul. 2024]. 

SHARE

Other articles

© 2026 John Liot. All rights reserved.